-
Oct28
Controversial Moon Origin Theory Rewrites History
Filed under: Science & Technology, Space Science; Tagged as: blasphemy, denison university, densi, early solar system, eight times, equator, geologic record, geological society of america, giant impact, gravitational friction, gravitational pull, impact hypothesis, impact model, mantle, new twist, ocean water, orbit, orbits, portland ore, upper layersNo Comments
The moon may have been adopted by our planet instead of descended from it.If a new twist on a decades-old theory is right, conditions in the early solar system suggest the moon formed inside Mercury’s orbit and migrated out until it was roped into orbit around Earth.
The idea flies in the face of scientific consensus, known as the giant impact hypothesis, which holds that the moon formed from red-hot debris left over after a Mars-sized object collided with Earth around 4.5 billion years ago.
However, the moon has several curious traits that go unexplained with that theory, and Robert Malcuit of Denison University has argued for decades for an alternative view of our moon’s history.
Malcuit’s version of events is tantamount to cosmic blasphemy, but scientists have recently found 4 billion-year-old minerals in Australia that suggest our planet was too cool to have sustained a cataclysmic moon-forming impact early in its history.
“Everything in the giant impact model is hot, hot, hot,” he said. “It’s incompatible with what we see in the geologic record. Earth is cool enough at that time to have ocean water on its surface.”
Malcuit’s computer modeling studies, which he has worked on since the 1980s, show that it is possible for Earth’s gravitational pull to capture the moon.
At first, the moon’s orbits would have been highly elliptical, swinging close to Earth and then far away about eight times a year.
The gravitational pull from each pass would have stretched the planet 18 to 20 kilometers (11.2 to 12.4 miles) near the equator, churning the hot mantle and crust. Rocks closer to the poles, like those found today in Australia, would have been spared. The upper layers of the newly-captured moon would have melted from gravitational friction, until the satellite’s orbit stabilized about 3 billion years ago.
Malcuit presented his theory at the annual meeting of the Geological Society of America in Portland, Ore.
Traditionally, scientists cite the moon’s low density and a lack of iron as reasons why it came from Earth — the giant impact skimmed light material off Earth’s upper layers and flung it into orbit.
“I think this it is highly unlikely,” that Malcuit’s idea is correct, Jack Lissauer of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration in Moffett Field, Calif., said. “Capture is very, very difficult. You have to have just the right velocity and very special parameters to all be just right.”
Lissauer allowed that the current giant impact theory of the moon’s formation may yet be revised, even replaced, but probably not by Malcuit’s capture model. The fact that Earth was cool 4 billion years ago doesn’t mean the moon was captured.
“Heat from the impact dissipated very quickly,” he said. “It wouldn’t take 100 million years, and it certainly wouldn’t take 500 million. The impact is not going to affect Earth at 4 billion years ago.”
Tags: blasphemy, denison university, densi, early solar system, eight times, equator, geologic record, geological society of america, giant impact, gravitational friction, gravitational pull, impact hypothesis, impact model, mantle, new twist, ocean water, orbit, orbits, portland ore, upper layers
Related posts:
Leave a Reply
Site Status
Freelance Jobs At Scriptlance
- Magento WebsiteI need a Magento Ecommerce Expert to develop my B2C website. I will provide a layered .psd to be used for the design. The site will consist of a basic store (homepage, dynamic category page, dynamic product page) The site will also include the following integrations: 1) Powerreviewsexpress.com for user reviews on product page 2) Google earth integration. I need to be able to add a .kmz file to each item in the back end. The .kmz needs to be displayed using the google earth plugin 3) custom…
- Clone Value-domain Tools Site Need a CMS website value- domain tools site. I need the design and features of www.sitelogr.com. (This script must be able to pull out different website data and post inside mysql database and on the site, this script should work amazingly fast and be completely bug-free. It must be easy to use some include function on any site and upload the script file to the server / install the db – and make the script show the scrapped/generated data.) SEO friendly links, AJAX, commented code/or docume…
- Clone Site And Applications We require a Complete Clone of www.studiom.com.au's site including the Envisage application. 1) I want a website with a strong CMS at the backend for us to upload text, images, videos on the site. There will also be a blog section in the front end. 2) We need an application like Envisage where a user visiting the site will be able to select the exterior, interior,kitchen etc of a house(Which we will supply for you to implement) and change its look by selecting and assigning material of th…
- JoomlaNeed to add some features inside phocadownload. Please do not bid if you do not have experience and ability to complete project fast and make a good work. Need this done in not more than a week since it is is not a lot of modification. Would love to have reliable and experienced person to work with since I have a lot more joomla projects that are coming. Project description: This component is phoca download that I like because it has play and preview features but I need following to be done. …
- Swoopo.com Auctions CloneIm looking for a team to develop a swoopo.com auctions clone in functions with a new aspect and in spanish language (translations could be done by me) I dont think that i have to give more details , just visit the web to see the features.
- Tv On Pc SoftwareLooking to rebrand a TV on PC Software application. The app should be windows XP – windows 7 Compatible. I will also need monthly channel updates. If you have a Mac version I would also be interested. I am not looking to make something from scratch so please dont ask. If you have please open a PMB with more details. Sample of the App is a plus.
- Website Design WorkHello, I am looking for an experienced Web designer to build some simple website pages as a test with the intention to have him build sites on a fulltime basis. The designer should have excellent experience with Photoshop, Dreamweaver, Flash, CSS, & other web designing tools. Joomla experience would be an asset. I am only looking for experienced designers that can build html (with flash, etc.) professional sites in excellent time frames (1 day for 3 pages if i give you an exact example s…
Partner links
Breaking News
- Deal because Headley is a double agent?Sources have told TIMES NOW that the possibility of LeT operative David Headley might get a lighter term. This clearly points towards him being a double agent. It’s learnt that a deal with Headley is being struck under the profer agreement. Now, the profer agreement allows the co-accused to strike a deal with federal prosecutors in exchnage for information against the main accused.…
- RJD Supporters lunge for cash garlandIt turned out to be an anti-climax for suspended RJD Rajya Sabha MP – Ejaz Ali as he arrived at the Patna airport. First were the flower garlands – and then perhaps taking a leaf out of the BSP book, the supporters presented Ejaz Ali with a cash garland. However, unlike what happened at Maya’s well orchestrated rally, here there was complete pandemonium. Supporters the moment they saw the money lunged for the currency notes. In the end all that Ejaz Ali was left with were flowers – and all the notes gone.…
Our Friends
Twitter links powered by Tweet This v1.6.1, a WordPress plugin for Twitter.